If your web supplier went bust tonight, what would you still own?

· · Infrastructure Security

Your website is probably run by someone else. An agency built it, a hosting company keeps it online, and a form on the contact page sends enquiries somewhere you have never had to think about. Most businesses have never asked what happens to all of that if the company holding it stops trading on a Friday afternoon.

Hundreds of GP practices in England and Wales found out in October. Their websites, online consultation forms, and chatbots went offline when the supplier behind them collapsed, and the practices had little or no warning. A GP surgery's arrangement with its website provider looks a lot like yours with your web agency, which is why it is worth ten minutes of your time.

What happened to the GP websites

Silicon Practice, the trading name of Schappit Ltd, built and hosted websites for GP surgeries, along with an online consultation tool called FootFall. Earlier in October the company went into administration. Some practice websites started returning errors. Others disappeared entirely. NHS England says fewer than 10 per cent of England's more than 6,000 GP surgeries were affected, and told patients to phone or visit their practice instead.

The detail worth reading twice is in a letter from NHS England's chief technology officer, Kevin Humphries, seen by The Register. He asked practices to preserve any historical patient information that had never been moved into their clinical systems, to stop new requests piling up in a consultation backlog nobody could reach, and to find other ways for patients to get in touch. Practices were also told to consider whether they need to report to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), because a personal data breach covers the "availability, integrity, confidentiality or recoverability of personal data", not just theft.

That point is easy to miss. Several practices warned patients that forms submitted shortly before the shutdown may never have reached staff. Nobody stole those requests. They are simply stuck inside a company that no longer answers the phone.

It is also worth noting that Silicon Practice had been added to a government buying framework in July. Being on an approved list told practices the supplier had passed a check at one point. It did not tell them what would happen if it failed.

Why a collapse is worse than an outage

We wrote recently about the suppliers you could not work without for a day. An outage usually ends, because the supplier wants you back. Insolvency works differently. Once administrators are appointed, their job is to get the best result for the company's creditors. Keeping your website running costs money, and nobody inside a failed company is working on your move to someone else.

Insolvency is not the only way a supplier can lose everything at once. On the night of 1 November, an attacker got into the systems that manage the whole of Beget, a large Russian hosting company with more than 200,000 customers, and ran scripts that erased its servers. The backups went with them. Beget says one type of server backup was lost completely, and that file backups will be available for only about half of the affected customers. "Unfortunately, it is impossible to recover all data," it said. A backup kept by the same supplier, on the same systems, is not a copy you own.

Three things tend to get stuck inside a failed web supplier:

  • Your domain. If the agency registered your web address in its own name or its own account, you may not control the address your customers type. If it also runs your DNS, the system that tells the internet where your website and email live, your email can stop too.
  • Your site and its content. The pages, images, and design live on the supplier's servers. Without your own copy, you rebuild from memory.
  • What people sent you. Enquiries, bookings, and uploaded documents. If submissions sit in the supplier's system rather than arriving in an inbox you own, that is personal data you are still responsible for, and may no longer be able to reach.

Five checks for whoever looks after your IT

These take an afternoon at most, and every one is easier to do while the supplier is still answering emails.

  1. Look up who your domain is registered to. The registrant should be your business, and the login to the registrar account should be yours, not the agency's. If it is not, ask for it to be transferred now.
  2. Find out who runs your DNS, and get a login. If it is the agency, you need to be able to change where your website and email point without their help.
  3. Hold a current copy of the site. A full backup or export stored somewhere you control, not only on the supplier's server. Repeat it whenever the site changes.
  4. Check where form submissions go. Ideally every submission arrives by email at an address you own, and nothing important exists only in the supplier's database.
  5. Make sure you have your own admin logins to the website, the hosting control panel, and any paid plugins or services, registered to your business rather than to someone at the agency.

Three questions for the contract

If you sign off the website budget, these are yours to ask.

  • Who owns the domain, the site, and the content? The contract should say you do, in writing.
  • What happens when we leave? How much notice, what format your data and content come back in, and how quickly.
  • What happens if you stop trading? Is there an agreed handover, and for anything custom-built, is the code held somewhere you can get to?

Ask your supplier to confirm the answers by email. A good supplier will reply within a day, and a slow or vague answer tells you something too.

One GP and open-source campaigner, Marcus Baw, has published a free replacement website template so practices can bring their sites back in house. Most businesses will never need to go that far. They need to know that if the supplier vanished tonight, the domain, the content, and the enquiries would still be theirs.

How Steelwise can help

Working out what your suppliers hold that you could not easily get back, and what your contracts say about getting it, is part of the infrastructure reviews we do. Get in touch.

Further reading

← All filings